home *** CD-ROM | disk | FTP | other *** search
- <text>
- <title>
- Joint Press Conference Concluding the Conference
- </title>
- <article>
- <hdr>
- Foreign Policy Bulletin, January-April 1992
- The Reorganization of Europe: Joint Press Conference Concluding
- the Conference, January 23, 1992
- </hdr>
- <body>
- <p>Secretary Baker. Ladies and gentlemen, I'd like to begin
- with a statement before turning to each of the cochairs of this
- conference for statements of their own, and, after our opening
- comments, we will, of course, take your questions. Please feel
- free to direct your questions to any one of the 54 heads of
- delegations that are seated here.
- </p>
- <p> Let me begin by saying that our discussions have been
- productive, and they have centered on concrete and coordinated
- actions. In our meetings, 47 nations and 7 international
- organizations have rolled up their sleeves, they've gotten down
- to work, and they've produced some tangible results. Let me
- review some of these with you.
- </p>
- <p> First of all, we have agreed to proposed to the New
- Independent States that a contact group of conference
- participants meet in Minsk next week to review the working
- group action plans. These independent states have already
- provided us with preliminary assessments of their priority
- needs, along with lists of city and oblast level officials and
- voluntary officials who can serve as points of contact for our
- future efforts.
- </p>
- <p> Next week's meeting will begin more systematic
- follow-through between international donors and the New
- Independent States themselves.
- </p>
- <p> Secondly, as the EC announced yesterday, the EC will host a
- follow-on conference in Lisbon within 90 to 120 days to assess
- how the work coming out of the conference here is proceeding in
- dealing with the emergency, where we need to expand our
- efforts, how we might further improve international
- coordination, and my colleague from Portugal will probably have
- more to say about that during the course of his presentation in
- just a moment. We also welcome Japan's effort to host a possible
- third conference.
- </p>
- <p> Third, the working group cochairs have produced detailed
- plans of action in food, medicine, shelter, energy, and
- technical assistance. These plans of action are intended to be
- working documents that will guide the cochairs as they take
- concrete steps to coordinate emergency assistance and to
- interact with the New Independent States.
- </p>
- <p> My cochair colleagues will perhaps go into more detail with
- you concerning these, but we are summarizing these actions for
- you, and we will distribute fact sheets as soon as we possibly
- can, and I hope it's shortly after we conclude here.
- </p>
- <p> Fourth, I would like to say that Ambassador Richard Armitage
- will serve as the operational on-the-ground coordinator of
- emergency assistance for the United States. He has already begun
- consultations with other participants to the conference on how
- best to mesh operational plans for emergency shipments and how
- best to reduce the danger of food and medical shipments being
- diverted.
- </p>
- <p> NATO in particular has offered to provide logistic support.
- Other participants are also appointing counterparts to Mr.
- Armitage.
- </p>
- <p> Fifth, many participants have made a number of proposals,
- not only for international coordination but also relating to
- their individual contributions. The European Community has
- already demonstrated its deep commitment to this effort and has
- made it clear that it will continue to do so.
- </p>
- <p> I have been told that over half the participants yesterday
- and today presented some new idea or initiative to meet
- emergency humanitarian needs.
- </p>
- <p> Most importantly, proposals came from Latin American and the
- Persian Gulf, as well as Asia and Europe, including the Nordic
- countries, the Central and Eastern Europeans, and others, as
- well as the European Community. So think it's fair to say that
- we truly have a global effort.
- </p>
- <p> In this respect, this conference is just the start of a
- continuing effort to intensify and to coordinate a global
- response to this emergency. Expert level discussion focusing on
- specific aspects of this emergency will continue in the weeks
- ahead.
- </p>
- <p> And, finally, ladies and gentlemen, let me take off my hat
- as host for just a moment to briefly mention some specific U.S.
- initiatives that have emerged as a result of this conference.
- And, again, we will provide you with a list as soon as it has
- been compiled and, hopefully, shortly after this press
- conference.
- </p>
- <p> These initiatives include such things as shipping
- appropriate Department of Defense excess medical stocks,
- establishing partnerships between U.S. hospitals and their
- counterparts' providing logistics support to U.S. private sector
- groups who wish to ship medicine or food; putting up to 3,000
- farm volunteers on the ground; establishing housing advisers on
- the ground; creating a training program for grassroots democracy
- with up to 500 participants; establishing a Eurasian foundation
- for democracy, free enterprise, and training in leadership and
- management.
- </p>
- <p> Putting these initiatives into practice will be made easier
- by the diplomatic missions that we are establishing in the New
- Independent States. By the end of next week, the United States
- will have diplomats on the ground in Minsk, Alma-Ata, Yerevan,
- and Bisnkek, in addition to those that are already in Moscow
- and Kiev. We also look forward to creating missions in the
- other states once we have established diplomatic relations with
- those states.
- </p>
- <p> Now, before turning to my cochairs, I'd like to announce one
- additional initiative. Beginning on February 10 and for one to
- two weeks thereafter, the United States will undertake an
- airlift of critical emergency assistance shipments. During this
- time, the U.S. Air Force will fly 54 sorties of critical medical
- and food shipments to cities in Russia and the New Independent
- States.
- </p>
- <p> The first C-5s will leave on February 10 from Rhein-Main Air
- Base in Frankfurt. We hope to airlift food and medical supplies
- to each of the twelve New Independent States, provided the
- determination is made that they can be delivered safely. To
- ensure shipments are adequately managed, distributed, and
- monitored, the United States will deploy immediately teams
- consisting of Department of Defense, Office of Foreign Disaster
- Assistance, and Agency for International Development personnel
- and others. These teams will manage the delivery to targeted
- groups and locations, including, for example, orphanages and
- hospitals.
- </p>
- <p> Of course, no airlift could ever come close to meeting all
- the needs of the people of the New Independent States. But this
- airlift that we are calling Operation Provide Hope can help
- deliver the food and medical supplies that are critically
- needed. Above all, Operation Provide Hope can vividly show the
- peoples of the former Soviet Union that those that once prepared
- for war with them now have the courage and the conviction to use
- their militaries to say, "We will wage a new peace."
- </p>
- <p> Now we will hear from the working group cochairs, and I
- would ask each cochair, if they would, to identify themselves
- and your working group. We will proceed in the order that groups
- have made presentations to the conference, so we will begin the
- Food Working Group and Foreign Minister Genscher of Germany, to
- be followed by the United Kingdom, Canada, Japan, Italy, The
- Netherlands, Venezuela, the EC, NATO and Portugal.
- Hans-Dietrich.
- </p>
- <p> Foreign Minister Genscher. At the outset of my statement, I
- should first of all like to express my gratitude to the
- American Government and Jim Baker for the initiative.
- </p>
- <p> We Germans consider this initiative as part and parcel of a
- long standing and good and well-proven American tradition. When
- we heard of this initiative for the first time, we were reminded
- of the Marshall Plan that was implemented for the destroyed
- Europe after the Second World War. We were reminded of the
- airlift to Berlin, and we once again experience this vast and
- big country is initiating something that is meant to make the
- peoples in the world aware of the fact that we have to assist
- the successor states of the Soviet Union.
- </p>
- <p> When I speak of the peoples of the world, I think not only
- of the North American democracies, of Europe, but I think also
- of other countries--the Asian countries, the industrialized
- countries in the Asian region, and the Gulf States.
- </p>
- <p> This is why we strongly supported this initiative at the
- outset. We believe that this initiative will be allowing us to
- mobilize the international public. A process has been started.
- So the effect is going to be a mobilizing one, and step by step
- this process is going to make a contribution due to the fact
- that the sensitivities of people has been increased, so the
- outcome will be greater efficiency and greater contributions.
- </p>
- <p> On the German side, Ambassador Dieckmann has been for a
- couple of weeks and months already the coordinator for relief
- programs and actions. We have already carried out more than 300
- airlifts. We have carried out transportation by rail and by sea.
- We want to keep up the momentum, and this is why it is important
- that first of all we try to turn to the addresses, so to speak--the recipients, the countries to which the goods are to be
- brought, are to be informed, the Commonwealth of Independent
- States. Then we are going to have the follow-up conference in
- Lisbon; and the World Economic Summit which will be convened in
- Munich--Germany is going to be the host--is going to
- concentrate on assistance to the successor states of the former
- Soviet Union as one of the priority issues.
- </p>
- <p> I should, first of all, like to report on the work of the
- Working Group on Food. This is the most urgent problem. To
- avoid any illusion, I shall hasten to add that we have reached
- the result [conclusion] that we not only have to discuss food
- aid for this winter, but--if we are to be realistic--we
- should also not lose sight of the next winter to come. That is
- to say that in the meantime, we have to try to do everything in
- our power in order to do away with weak spots in the food supply
- inside the Soviet Union.
- </p>
- <p> At the same time, we should be aware of the fact that the
- production capacities are sufficient. So what we should try to
- do is to try to avoid that there are losses between the
- harvesting and the consumer. So the transport from, as I said,
- the point where the grain, for example, is being harvested,
- where it is being stored, are not too high. The summer period
- should be used for this purpose.
- </p>
- <p> The result of this conference is that we are trying to
- identify the recipient states and areas. Here, we think first
- and foremost of the industrial conurbations, the industrial
- centers. This is not only true for Moscow and St. Petersburg but
- also true for other Republics. Therefore, it is going to be
- necessary that we concentrate on all conurbations and industrial
- areas.
- </p>
- <p> This is especially true with respect to the people in the
- most urgent need for help--the old people, the children, the
- ill people in hospitals an old-age homes.
- </p>
- <p> We already installed a task force in Moscow and St.
- Petersburg. Many troops are already there. They are involved in
- the process of distribution. And then we have the
- nongovernmental organizations who have been involved and the
- relief organizations. So this work has now to be coordinated.
- </p>
- <p> We, the donor countries, wish to perhaps to try to agree on
- how to distribute the work amongst ourselves, so that we can
- avoid a duplication of effort and so that we can make a
- contribution to guaranteeing the sufficient supply where it is
- needed.
- </p>
- <p> The second topic on which I have to report is housing, the
- housing area--and that is, indeed, again, a very urgent
- problem. In the Soviet Union, there is not a lack of 100,000 or
- millions of houses, or housing units, but tens of millions.
- During the withdrawal of the troops of the Red Army from
- Germany, Germany has committed itself to the construction of
- houses, and we have been using eight billion Deutchmarks for
- this purpose. The funds that are available are not only being
- used for work--construction work being carried out by German
- companies--but about 50 percent of the funds are being paid
- to companies from other countries, such as Turkish construction
- companies, because they already have gained experience in that
- field in the Soviet Union, and also companies coming from
- Central and Eastern European countries who traditionally have
- always had good relations in this field with the Soviet Union.
- </p>
- <p> Therefore, I expect--and that again was a result of our
- negotiations--that those countries who are, geographically
- speaking, far off from the Soviet Union (so that they cannot
- easily make available their own productive capacities to the
- Soviet Union) that they at least provide the funds and order
- and task other companies with the execution of certain actions,
- who can then be used more effectively.
- </p>
- <p> That is one past of the way in which we can assist in this
- area and this sector. The second one is, how to deal with the
- urgent need for housing. We have to take effective measures
- that come into effect quickly--that is to say, we have to
- provide housing, not of a permanent nature. We call them
- "housing containers." They are not, as I said, of a permanent
- nature but meant for a transitional period so that we can cope
- with the urgent emergency situation.
- </p>
- <p> In the medium term, however, the housing sector has to
- create further capacities, and this has to take place in the
- Soviet Union itself. Germany is presently involved in the
- building up of full-housing combines in the Soviet Union so that
- they then, by way of providing help toward self-help, are in a
- position to increase their housing construction.
- </p>
- <p> Additionally, we also provide assistance in developing a
- private housing sector in the economy so that we try, in so
- doing, to make a contribution towards developing a genuine
- housing market in the Soviet Union.
- </p>
- <p> So the two areas on which I have to report to you--other
- colleagues are going to report on other areas--do have an
- effect that, if you take them together with the other working
- groups, constitute a clear signal. That is what this conference
- was meant to give--a signal going into three different
- directions.
- </p>
- <p> First of all, a signal directed to the people in our own
- countries--that is, that help is urgently required. And,
- second, a signal to those countries who, up to the present
- point in time, have stood aside and have not provided any
- assistance. And third--that is perhaps the most important
- point--a signal addressed to those people in the successor
- states of the Soviet Union, because they peacefully and
- convincingly have made a contribution, as democrats, towards
- overcoming a dictatorship. They now have to be able to realize
- that the democratic world is not only applauding them and
- standing aside and waiting to see what is going to happen, but
- that the democratic world is really determined to assist them
- in this difficult process of overcoming those serious problems.
- </p>
- <p> What is decisive here is that each and every citizen has to
- be made aware of the fact that the world is no longer divided.
- We have one united world; we have one united Europe; one united
- Germany.
- </p>
- <p> The peoples outside the former Soviet Union will not be able
- to live well off, in the long term, if the peoples or the people
- in the former Soviet Union are not well off, because our fates
- are linked, and this is why solidarity is called for. This is
- the signal, the appeal that has to emanate from this conference
- in Washington.
- </p>
- <p> I should like to thank Jim Baker very much for the fact that
- it was he who, together with the President of the United
- States, George Bush, created this initiative for this important--I'd even go so far to say historic--conference. Thank you.
- </p>
- <p> Secretary Baker. The United Kingdom. Mr. Bayne.
- </p>
- <p> Deputy Under Secretary of States for the United Kingdom
- Nicholas Bayne. As Foreign Minister Genscher has already
- indicated, this conference identified four objectives for food
- assistance to the New Independent States: to reduce hardship
- this winter; to strengthen the market in the food sector; to
- mobilize the new states' own food resources for next winter and
- beyond; and to reenforce economic reform.
- </p>
- <p> There is a great deal of food aid in the pipeline being
- delivered: about $500 million in grants and about $5 billion in
- credits with more being committed all the time.
- </p>
- <p> The key task we identified is to ensure this food gets to
- those that need it, in very difficult conditions. Five things
- are required:
- </p>
- <p> First: Targeting of cities and regions where the shortages
- are, making sure none are forgotten.
- </p>
- <p> Second: Pooling the experience of nongovernmental
- organizations and other agencies in distributing food to the
- needy.
- </p>
- <p> Third: Developing techniques of offering food grants for
- sale to strengthen markets.
- </p>
- <p> Fourth: In transport, using the facilities of neighboring
- countries to the new states--their ports, their railways--and using NATO's logistics if commercial networks fail.
- </p>
- <p> Fifth, and most important, coordinating delivery by donors
- on the spot in close partnership with the local authorities in
- the new states. On this, the European Community has made a start
- but it's now necessary to go wider.
- </p>
- <p> Food credits are much larger in amounts than food grants,
- and they remain a major source of food imports for the
- population of new states. We need to make sure that none of the
- new Republics is forgotten, and we should make maximum use of
- sources of such food in the East European countries and other
- traditional exporters.
- </p>
- <p> Technical assistance in the food sector is essential to make
- emergency aid unnecessary in the future. More and more
- countries are taking part in this technical assistance effort.
- The priorities are, as Minister Genscher has said, food
- processing, transport and marketing, plus better farming
- practices and better storage, all in the context of getting more
- competition into the food sector as into the entire economies
- of the new states.
- </p>
- <p> The food group's next task after this conference is to
- establish contacts with the new states and to work with key
- international institutions to prepare the next conference at
- Lisbon.
- </p>
- <p> Finally, let me say how deeply the United Kingdom is engaged
- in this collective effort to help the new Republics. Foreign
- Secretary Hurd, my Minister, came here direct from Moscow,
- Kiev, and Alma-Ata. We are deeply involved in the European
- Communities food grants, food credits, and technical assistance
- programs, and we are sending people to take part in their
- monitoring task force.
- </p>
- <p> Under our bilateral programs, animal food from Britain is
- arriving even now for farmers near St. Petersburg while our
- experts are advising on bread distribution in Moscow. We have
- just announced a new program of medical aid worth nearly $4
- million.
- </p>
- <p> So we welcome very greatly this successful conference, and
- we welcome the initiative of Secretary Baker in calling it.
- Thank you.
- </p>
- <p> Secretary Baker. Thank you, Mr. Bayne. May we hear form
- Canada.
- </p>
- <p> Canadian Assistant Deputy Minister, European Branch, David
- Wright. Mr. Secretary, I want first of all to extend Canada's
- thanks and congratulations to you for taking the initiative to
- convene this important meeting and for managing such an
- important and productive discussion.
- </p>
- <p> We have the unique opportunity to support the historic
- economic and political transformation of the newly independent
- countries of the former Soviet Union. Canada will play its part
- in meeting this challenge.
- </p>
- <p> To date, our assistance, in the form of credits and grants
- and other forms of technical assistance, totals almost $2
- billion.
- </p>
- <p> Canada was pleased to act as cochair of the Food Working
- Group. As my colleagues have indicated on the food situation
- over the past two days have demonstrated a spirit of cooperation
- and a strong commitment to provide further help--both
- immediate aid and longer-term technical assistance.
- </p>
- <p> As our Minister emphasized yesterday, hungry people cannot
- embrace reform. We must now work hard on the ground in the
- newly independent states to ensure that food is delivered,
- especially to those most in need. Only concrete results will
- ensure that the reform process succeeds. Canada is strongly
- committed to working with others here to that end. Thank you,
- Mr. Chairman.
- </p>
- <p> Secretary Baker. Thank you. Japan.
- </p>
- <p> Deputy Foreign Minister of Japan Kunihiko Saito. Mr.
- Secretary, on behalf of the Foreign Minister of Japan, who had
- to leave earlier, I would like first to thank the Government of
- the United States and particularly Secretary Baker for taking
- the initiative in convening this historical conference.
- </p>
- <p> I think the conference was very productive, and the
- discussion which took place yesterday and today in the
- conference will form an excellent basis for taking concrete
- steps in a coordinated and efficient manner.
- </p>
- <p> Japan cochaired the group on medical assistance. The gist of
- the results of the discussion which took place in this working
- group is contained in a sheet of paper which, I believe, has
- been distributed to you. I won't go into details explaining
- this paper.
- </p>
- <p> This working group has agreed to propose a four point
- program. It has also agreed to take specific steps in the coming
- weeks and months. I believe these points were generally accepted
- by the participating countries.
- </p>
- <p> Now a few words on the position of Japan. We believe that we
- should help the Newly Independent States in their efforts to
- introduce and establish democracy and a free market economy.
- They are having a difficult time now, and we should make every
- effort to extend emergency assistance for humanitarian
- considerations.
- </p>
- <p> From such a viewpoint, my government, in addition to the
- $2.5 billion package which was announced in October last year,
- recently decided to donate an amount of 6.5 billion yen--roughly $50 million--to the International Red Cross and Red
- Crescent Societies for food and medical assistance. We shall
- continue to make efforts in cooperation with other countries
- and organizations to extend humanitarian emergency aid to the
- New Independent States.
- </p>
- <p> Finally, I'd like to mention that my Minister announced
- yesterday, as was mentioned by Secretary Baker, that Japan is
- prepared to host the third conference to follow up the second
- conference to reconvene in Lisbon. Thank you, Mr. Secretary.
- </p>
- <p> Italian Foreign Minister Gianni de Michelis. Ladies and
- gentlemen, I would like to add only a few considerations on
- what already Hans-Dietrich Genscher has said on the problem of
- shelters.
- </p>
- <p> The first consideration is that now, after the discussion in
- our working group, it is clear to everybody that the shortage
- in housing in all the twelve Republics in the former Soviet
- Union could be, in the near future, not only a big social and
- humanitarian problem, but also a big political problem.
- </p>
- <p> It is, maybe, the worst bottleneck which all the Republics
- will find in front of them during the first phase of
- restoration of the reorganization of their society and their
- economy. A failure in over-passing that bottleneck could really
- bring very dangerous tensions and destabilization in most of
- these Republics.
- </p>
- <p> The second consideration is that it is clear, also taking
- into account the huge dimension of the problem and that fact
- that, at least with respect to the problems of relocating the
- army personnel and giving an answer to the problem of
- international refugees, we are to face a problem of almost 1.52
- millions of people. There is no possibility for the Republics
- to face this problem by only mobilizing their internal
- resources. Obviously better mobilization and faster mobilization
- of internal resources is absolutely a necessity.
- </p>
- <p> So the conclusion is that if we are trying--as we are
- trying in this conference--to shape a shorter-run, focussed
- strategy, not only for emergency or humanitarian aid but really
- for coordinated assistance to the Republics, for avoiding the
- failure of their efforts toward democracy and a market economy,
- something must be done also through the external foreign
- cooperation.
- </p>
- <p> So we have really, at the end of this working group, clearly
- targeted three main and important and urgent objectives.
- </p>
- <p> The first is obviously to start--through technical
- assistance and technical advice, to help them to reorganize
- their internal national building industry.
- </p>
- <p> Secondly, to prepare ourselves to face, through the
- international organizations, emergencies which could arise in
- a very sudden and wide way in the near future, especially as a
- consequence of the reorganization of the relations among the
- different Republics.
- </p>
- <p> Third, to organize a joint international effort on a
- bilateral and multilateral basis for promoting, through
- technical assistance but also through financial participation
- from abroad, a sort of shock program of the building of shelters
- or houses. That could become, especially in the next two years--in the next two winters--probably the first emergency among
- the many which we have discussed in our groups.
- </p>
- <p> So there is a problem of coordination; there is a problem of
- better identification--pragmatically, on the ground--of the
- priorities. But there is also the problem of understanding that
- we have to mobilize important financial resources from outside
- and take into account the level of the perception of the
- problem in our nations--a society problem.
- </p>
- <p> Probably on this point, it would be a necessity to make a
- big effort of informing our public opinion at home and for
- informing parliaments and governments. I think that on the basis
- of these results, there is another demonstration of the
- importance of this conference. We are grateful to Secretary
- Baker and to the Government of the United States for having
- given to everybody this opportunity, which I really hope does
- start a new phase of real action with respect to this very
- important problem.
- </p>
- <p> Netherlands Foreign Minster H. van den Broek. Thank you, Mr.
- Chairman. We were very pleased, as the Netherlands, to have the
- honor to cochair the energy working group together with our
- friends from Venezuela. Needless to say, also in the energy
- field, the problems in the CIS countries are manifold, are of
- short-term nature, or at least require short-term and
- longer-term approaches.
- </p>
- <p> In the production field, be it oil, coal, or electricity,
- production has significantly decreased in the New Independent
- States due to a lack of internal investment, dislocations in
- the equipment supply system, and a general economic decline,
- including strikes in energy-producing sectors. The lack of a
- satisfactory legal regime has hindered foreign investment so
- far.
- </p>
- <p> But also the disruptions in the distribution system have
- caused severe energy shortages in several regions of the New
- Independent States.
- </p>
- <p> One could further mention the huge wastage in energy
- consumption. If we only considered that on an annual basis,
- what has flared in gas by the CIS states amounts to a volume of
- 35 billion cubicmeters on an annual basis, which exactly the
- annual consumption of gas in The Netherlands. Pure waste.
- </p>
- <p> Adequate supplies of energy, needless to say, are crucial to
- sustaining the market economic reform movements in the new
- states.
- </p>
- <p> So what do we do about it? What has the working group
- established as a plan of action?
- </p>
- <p>-- Starting consultations with the New Independent States
- immediately on urgent needs and priorities and the means of
- providing assistance; a mixed public and private mission of
- experts from the EC, the IEA, and supported by Canada, Japan,
- the U.S., and Venezuela will start consultations early next
- month.
- </p>
- <p>-- Plan of action assuring adequate and prompt fuel supplies--this is short term--for the transport of food and medical
- assistance from ports of entry to points of consumption. NATO
- could contribute in this effort.
- </p>
- <p>-- Supporting the efforts of the Ukraine and Kuznetsk--Russian Basins--to improve productivity; and ensure supplies
- for power generators.
- </p>
- <p>-- Increase health and safety conditions and raise the quality
- of life.
- </p>
- <p>-- Seeking to increase the energy efficiency of heating
- districts in the large cities, with a particular emphasis on
- assuring improvements in home heating and critical industries
- such as food processing.
- </p>
- <p>-- Working with New Independent States to anticipate and
- respond to fuel and electricity needs for agriculture and food
- processing for 1992 spring planting and for harvest.
- </p>
- <p>-- In addition, developing a regional approach to meet fuel
- problems in the fishing and fish-processing industries in the
- Far East regions.
- </p>
- <p> We will start a dialogue with the energy-producing New
- Independent States to encourage adequate supplies to areas with
- significant shortfalls in fuels such as Armenia and Kirgizstan.
- </p>
- <p> Regarding the private sector:
- </p>
- <p>-- Promoting private industry efforts, with the assistance of
- the EBRD and the World Bank, to overhaul pipelines and gas
- compressor stations in Russian, Ukraine, Byelorussia, with the
- objectives of cutting transmission losses;
- </p>
- <p>-- Immediately offering technical expertise in the management,
- maintenance, and operation of pipelines under market conditions;
- </p>
- <p>-- Working also with the private industry to provide spare
- parts and essential equipment, management skills, and resources
- to rapidly restart production in existing petroleum fields, and
- encouraging the New Independent States to open fields for the
- private sector;
- </p>
- <p>-- Also provide assistance to improve energy efficiency of
- existing refineries.
- </p>
- <p> All of these are clear objectives, but it is also
- self-evident that success in meeting the energy challenges of
- the New Independent States will depend on the support of those
- states, the engagement of the private sector, and providing
- assistance in a manner that supports and encourages
- market-oriented reform.
- </p>
- <p> The lead time in the energy sector is generally longer, but
- short-term visible results can be achieved.
- </p>
- <p> So this, Mr. Chairman, is the outcome of the work in the
- Energy Working Group, and the briefing of the New Independent
- States on the conference results will be undertaken by the
- cochairs in cooperation with the contact group in Minsk next
- week. Then the Working Group will collect, assess, and
- distribute information on existing bilateral programs. And
- immediately following the consultative mission, the working
- group will meet to evaluate results in order to finalize the
- plan of action, including the implementation mechanism.
- </p>
- <p> May I end by thanking the American administration, in
- particular Jim Baker, for the tremendous efforts of organizing
- this conference, which also, in our view, has been a very
- productive and effective one. Thank you so much.
- </p>
- <p> Secretary Baker. Minster Duran.
- </p>
- <p> Venezuelan Foreign Minister Armando Duran. Thank you, Mr.
- Chairman. I have very little to add to what Minister van den
- Broek has just explained about the energy group.
- </p>
- <p> I would like to clarify, though, certain aspects about oil
- production and distribution, which is the core problem at least
- in the next few months and the next few years.
- </p>
- <p> There is a very clear decrease in production of oil in the
- New Independent States, but still that is not the big problem.
- The production of oil has come down to about nine million
- barrels per day, which is about two million barrels more than
- what is necessary for national consumption in the ex-Soviet
- Union, which is about seven million. That is why they are still
- exporting--about two million.
- </p>
- <p> The big problem with the ex-Soviet Union is the disruption
- of the distribution system. They are producing, but they are
- not distributing oil and fuel to places that should receive it.
- As a matter of fact, that is part of the bigger problem--which
- is the disruption of the communist production and distribution
- system, and the impossibility, at least up to now, to
- substitute that system for a free-market system.
- </p>
- <p> In that respect, Venezuela is engaged to aid the ex-Soviet
- Union with the--well, Venezuela is a developing country, so
- we cannot be donors of anything except our expertise in the
- successful management of our oil industry.
- </p>
- <p> So Venezuela will be present at the Minsk meeting next week,
- with out experts, to provide whatever experience that we can
- provide them, to help rebuild or build a distribution system
- and the modernization of an oil industry that in the last few
- years has been really sliding into obsolescence and
- inefficiency.
- </p>
- <p> That is the engagement that Venezuela is willing to make to
- help to aid the New Independent States to rebuild their oil
- industry.
- </p>
- <p> I would also like to take this opportunity to express our
- appreciation to the Government of the United States and, of
- course, Secretary Baker for this initiative which allows us to
- participate in such an ambitious project--to work toward
- peace and world security. Thank you very much, Mr. Secretary.
- </p>
- <p> Secretary Baker. Thank you, Mr. Minister. Mr. Andriessen.
- </p>
- <p> EC Vice President Frans Andriessen. I would like to thank the
- United States and in particular the Secretary of State for
- organizing this conference.
- </p>
- <p> This conference has been a successful and productive one,
- addressing the right issues at the right time. It has set
- priorities for technical assistance which will remain
- unavoidable, indispensable for the countries concerned.
- </p>
- <p> For this conference to prove equally valuable in practice,
- plans must now be followed by action and results.
- </p>
- <p> As the other countries in Central and Eastern Europe, the
- New Independent States can count on the European Community to
- see that plans are followed by action. We are encouraged by
- this conference to note that other share this commitment. Thank
- you, Mr. Chairman.
- </p>
- <p> Secretary Baker. Thank you, Frans. Manfred Woerner.
- </p>
- <p> NATO Secretary General Manfred Woerner. Ladies and
- gentlemen, here I participate as the Secretary General of the
- Atlantic Alliance which, as you all know, has been the principal
- opponent to Soviet expansion. Now the same NATO is offering its
- assistance to the peoples of the former Soviet Union. Nothing
- could better symbolize the end of the Cold War.
- </p>
- <p> We are replacing by deeds--and not only by words--confrontation by cooperation. I think we are sending a very
- powerful signal to the citizens of the former Soviet Union. We
- are no more enemies. We have become friends. We know it from
- the Russians and others. They want us to give such a signal.
- They want us to participate. Our offer of assistance is fully
- in line with one of the principal new tasks of our Alliance, to
- act as a center of stability for the whole of the Euro-Atlantic
- community.
- </p>
- <p> The principles which will govern NATO's contributions are:
- First, we will concentrate on those activities which no other
- nation or no other institution can do better; and second, we
- will act in closest cooperation with nations, international
- organizations, and of course recipient states.
- </p>
- <p> So NATO has offered a meaningful assistance in three areas:
- </p>
- <p>-- First, in the coordination of transport at the request of
- nations and international organizations;
- </p>
- <p>-- Second, in contributing to the overall task of distribution
- by offering logistical expertise and communication support; and
- </p>
- <p>-- Third, in the area of medical requirements, we could serve
- as a clearing house or we could assist any other organization
- acting as a clearing house.
- </p>
- <p> NATO's civil and military staffs have trained for years in
- the largest logistical task one can imagine: the transfer,
- reception, and onward movement of reenforcements to defend our
- nations in a major conflict. Fortunately enough, this danger
- has disappeared. But it would be incomprehensible, we think, if
- not inexcusable, if we hesitated to use our training and
- expertise in this tasks of similar logistical dimensions.
- </p>
- <p> At the end of the day, the purpose is the same--to project
- stability, to defend democracy, and to preserve peace. So we
- stand ready to respond to the need, and we are delighted to
- have seen during the conference that there was broad support by
- member nations and by non-member nations of NATO for our offer.
- Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
- </p>
- <p> Secretary Baker. Thank you, Manfred. For the EC Presidency,
- Minister Joao de Deus Pinheiro.
- </p>
- <p> Foreign Minister of Portugal Pinheiro. Ladies and gentlemen,
- I think that one of the first and foremost achievements of this
- Washington conference is the fact that it has brought together
- a large number of countries from all of the continents of our
- globe, and meet one common objective: to act together in a
- spirit of solidarity with the peoples of the New Independent
- States of the CIS; to help them succeed in their efforts in the
- difficult transition to democracy and market economy.
- </p>
- <p> This is, however, the first step of a process. Ahead lies
- the task of translating our commitments into effective and
- rapid results. We now need to ensure that the people in the new
- states and their authorities at every level join us as partners
- in this task. Our aim is to contribute to their efforts and help
- them to reach the objectives they have chosen.
- </p>
- <p> If we succeed in this enterprise, as we must, we shall not
- only have helped to provide relief to million of people, we
- shall have laid the best possible foundation for a new era of
- global solidarity. We shall need to build a strong momentum on
- the basis of our commitments at this Washington conference. The
- next few months will be used to get this momentum underway.
- </p>
- <p> Probably at the beginning of May, in the next conference to
- be held in Lisbon, we must bring the countries represented at
- the Washington conference together with the twelve new states
- of the CIS.
- </p>
- <p> Our approach is flexible and pragmatic. We will seek to
- mobilize all the existing resources of countries, international
- organizations, nongovernmental organizations and private
- enterprise. We do not envisage the creation of new
- international bureaucracies, but we must not have any illusion
- that the large scale efforts needed can become effective without
- the corresponding organization and coordination.
- </p>
- <p> The European Community and its member states will continue
- and further develop their considerable contributions to this
- enterprise. Let me finish by, in the name of us all, thank very
- warmly the United States Government and President Bush for
- having convened this conference, to congratulate you on the
- success which is a success of this conference, and to tell you
- that this means actual responsibility for the European Community
- and for Portugal. We gladly take this actual responsibility due
- to the success of this conference. Thank you very much.
- </p>
- <p> Secretary Baker. Thank you very much, Minister. Ladies and
- gentlemen, we'll be happy to respond now to your questions.
- Please direct your questions to whomever you wish to ask.
- </p>
- <p> Q. Secretary Baker and Secretary General Woerner. How great
- are the factions in the CIS countries that are calling for a
- return to the old order, and how strong is the chances of
- military takeovers in those countries?
- </p>
- <p> Secretary Baker. I think it's quite evident that one of the
- reasons that we are all here, and have been here over the
- course of the past two days, is because we have fought for--we have struggled for over 40 years and at the cost of many,
- many billions of dollars in defense of certain principles that
- everybody on this dais now shares, and in opposition to some
- competing principles.
- </p>
- <p> Democrats and reformers and people who believe as we do are
- now in power in the Republics of the former Soviet Union, in
- power in the New Independent States. It is very, very important
- to us that they succeed. I think if we felt that there were not
- threats to that success, we would not--perhaps not--be as
- vigorously engaged in the undertakings that we have been engaged
- in here today, albeit we still would be trying to respond to
- humanitarian needs.
- </p>
- <p> But it is very important that the democrats and reformers be
- given an opportunity to succeed, and that's part of what we're
- all about, and there is a threat.
- </p>
- <p> NATO Secretary General Woerner. In addition to what
- Secretary Baker just mentioned, as you know, NATO has
- established a Coordination Council, a Cooperation Council. We
- have started the liaison process with the countries of Central
- and Eastern Europe and have included the Soviet Union--or now
- I have to say the former Soviet Union--and we will take in,
- once they are recognized, the Independent States, just for the
- purpose to contribute to prevent such dangers, to realize, to
- happen, Just for the purpose to give them not only the
- impression, but the reality that they participate in an
- international process which makes a Europe whole and free a
- reality. And that is, I think, the main purpose of this
- undertaking, and I think we will be successful.
- </p>
- <p> Q. We read the proposals of the Bulgarian delegation, and
- the most interesting one is the question of the trilateral--the triangular operations.
- </p>
- <p> What is exactly the role of Bulgaria as you envisage it in
- such trilateral, triangular, operation? And the second
- question, can you give us later on, an interview? I mean, for
- Democratzia [newspaper published in Sofia]?
- </p>
- <p> Foreign Minister of Bulgaria Ganev. Thank you for the
- question, and thus giving a chance for people to hear more
- about Bulgaria, because lately the voice of Bulgaria is being
- heard ever more often, and there are good reasons for that. I'm
- thankful to Mr. Woerner for supporting the idea--not only
- Bulgaria's idea, but also the ideas of Poland and other
- countries, for using these triangular operations, because right
- now it is a question of assisting the democratic process, not
- only in the former Soviet Union, but also in Eastern Europe,
- including Bulgaria.
- </p>
- <p> Bulgaria has great capabilities through its ports--through
- its airports--also the production of agricultural goods,
- construction, housing, and this can be financially credited,
- funded, and thus not only the former Soviet Union will be
- assisted, but we will also assist the transition to market
- economy in countries like Bulgaria.
- </p>
- <p> As far as an interview with Democratzia Daily, it will be my
- pleasure to give one. Thank you.
- </p>
- <p> Q. Mr. Secretary, could you tell us, please, if there have
- been other contributions pledged beyond the President's
- contribution that we know of? Could you tell us, please, how
- these action programs will be funded, and there's been no word
- here of the criteria. Is there a consensus now as to how much
- of a commitment these 11-12 republics have to have to
- capitalism, or what you have to have the capitalism, or what you
- call free market economies, in order to qualify for humanitarian
- aid? Have the Germans and the Americans, for instance, come to
- terms?
- </p>
- <p> Secretary Baker. I didn't know that there was a significant
- difference between the Germans and the Americans, but let me
- say that with respect to criteria, we do not call for criteria
- insofar as pure humanitarian assistance is concerned. It is the
- position of the United States that we want, of course, to help
- those who share our values and our principles--those who are
- trying to make their efforts at reform succeed.
- </p>
- <p>(Released by the Office of the White House Secretary, January
- 28, 1992)
- </p>
- </body>
- </article>
- </text>
-